abdullrahman madi's picture

help me with your critique!!

so I am new to architectural photography but not photography in general, so I want you guys to give me some valuable feedback, (and Image of the founders memorial in AbuDhabi ,UAE)

Log in or register to post comments


Nic Nichols's picture

Help with what? This is beautiful!

Jessadayut Speers's picture

I'm no expert but maybe crop in a little more and or try a different sky

abdullrahman madi's picture

you mean more panoramic crop?

Jessadayut Speers's picture

I mean, I can see your focus on the monument and the cityscape. The sky is not too interesting and I think a more panoramic crop might be cool. Just my opinion. It is a solid photo overall though.

Rob Woodham's picture

I think it's a great shot. If i wanted to pick something, assuming the center sculpture is the intended subject, the right side being covered by the trees is a bit off-putting. Viewers who are interested in that particular sculpture are going to want to know what the right side looks like and if it's basically the same as the left. With the amount of tree cover, that's difficult. A little less cover would result in a shot where you can see enough that it's assumed to have the same features as the rest of the facade and that would be good enough.

Thanks for sharing it!

abdullrahman madi's picture

Agree with you Rob, this high frequency textured object ( tree) is too much distracting from the viewer from the main sculpture, that is what I thought while retouching the photo, thanks for the feedback.

John MacLean's picture

I like it, but it looks like it's either got some diffraction from too small of an f-stop, or it needs a tad more sharpening.

Todd Yates's picture

Love the lighting and feel of the image but for my taste, I find it a little loose. The smaller object on the right for me is distracting. if you moved in on the buildings and the monument I think it would also solve your problem with the trees on the right. Look forward to seeing more of your work.

abdullrahman madi's picture

Thanks for the feedback :)

I agree with most of the others. I like the light and clarity of the image. But the composition is a bit ambiguous. There are 3 main subjects in the photo. The text-thing on the right might not be as important as the square. The city-scape in the background is good for context and very cool! Alot of clients these days would probably want some people, but I lke it more without!

nice ps work